Shropshire v Norfolk: Battle of the Christmas Beef

To Norfolk for Christmas with the future in-laws. Norfolk, like Shropshire, is one of England’s most rural counties, and also one of the largest – spreading over 2,000 square miles (Shropshire is around 1,340 square miles).

Both counties are out of commuter range (the trains between Norfolk and London are even worse than the road links) and rely largely on agriculture and tourism for their economies, so have plenty in common.

The two proud counties even battled it out during the Minor Counties Cricket Cup last year at the picturesque village ground of Horsham – the Lords of Norfolk – with Shropshire winning in a thrilling match by the narrowest of margins – just 5 runs.

One of their closest similarities is being widely horse-mad (our table mats on Christmas Day were all of famous racehorses) as well as being one hell of a drive from London. When my fiancee rang me on a Wednesday afternoon in London a few months ago and casually (and unexpectedly) announced that she was ‘driving up for supper’  – a three hour drive from Chelsea – I knew she was going to have no problem living in Shropshire.

And my fiancee (Laura) seems to love it here at Upton Cressett, which is reached at the end of ‘the lonleiest of valleys in the world’ as John Betjeman wrote of the house in the 1951 Shell Guide To Shropshire. Another simillarity with Norfolk is that Shropshire is extremely cold.  Since Upton Cressett is on the top of a hill that you would expect to find in the Alps, the house is even colder than the rest of Shropshire. But again, my fiancee is used to sleeping in a bedroom with no heating, so she has settled in very quickly (she does, admittedly, adore her electirc blanket).
But there are also some major differences between Norfolk and Shropshire.

The most notable is what people eat.

A delicious traditional Christmas lunch – with rival Christmas puddings – was hosted at the house of my fiancee’s grandparents. Her grandfather has trained race horses in Norfolk for well over fifty years – and is still training winners.

The last time I had met my fiancee’s grandfather  – at Sunday lunch back in the summer  – he mentioned t at the end of the war, (he is in his eighties but exceptionally fit), whilst serving in Northern Italy, he had received a letter from his mother saying that war rationing meant that ‘cheese’ was almost impossible to come by in Norfolk and if he had any room in his kit-bag, could he bring some some back with him?

He dutifully bought a large Gorganzola, wrapped it in foil, and ‘smuggled’ it back to Norfolk in an old suitcase. It stank all the way – and took over a week – but such was the rarity of cheese in Norfolk, even the mouldy and crumbling old remains of the blue-veined Gorgonzola (which is made from unskimmed cow’s milk) was devoured by his family as if it were Russian caviar.

The reason that cheese was such a luxury and rarity in Norfolk during the war is that Norfolk is not a dairy county like Shropshire or Herefordshire. I am not saying there are NO cows in the county, but I have to say I didn’t see many herds around Fakenham, where my fiancee’s family live, or along the North Coast.

The latter is sometimes known as The Champagne Coast – famous for its crab and seafood. “If we are going out for lunch’ warned my fiancee shortly after I arrived.  ”Stick to fish and chips, Cromer crab, or pork. We have a lot of pigs in Norfolk’.

This lesson in basic rural economics was learnt on Boxing day when we went to have lunch at the recently refurbished  Victoria Inn (‘New look, new food, new rooms’) at Holkham before going for a walk along the beach. The Victoria (www.holkham.co.uk/victoria) is a chic boutique hotel and restaurant that was originally renovated by Viscount Coke and his wife Polly in 2011, and has now been re-invented again with a complete makeover. The dining room is pictured above.

The original Victoria boasted a chef who had worked in Ibiza, with a funky Rajastan country club rattan look.  The new Victoria is less colonial, more shabby leather Norfolk, more of a throw back to the cosy Victorian comfort of the 19th century original estate Inn (the Victoria was built by the agricultural revolutionary Coke of Norfolk  in 1838, the year after Queen Victoria was crowned).
The club chairs and shooting prints – or at least advice – is closer to the DNA of Thomas Coke”s (the first Earl Leicester) original Inn than the Indian colonial funk version. The interior is like a chic country house bistro and serves looks even better  (the battered cod is legendary) than before.  We loved the ‘new look’ – which seems more authentic – and began plotting escaping from London for a winter weekend mini-break walking along one of Norfolk’s finest ‘windswept’ beaches before our February wedding.

Then I noted the slightly disapproving look on my fiancee’s face when I chose the sirloin steak. The website (states that the beef is from one of the Holkham family farms, so no problem there surely? My fiancee ordered the pork belly, which arrived looking like a dish served at the Gavroche and was as exquisitely tender and delicious as it looked. My steak (£20) was one of the smallest pieces of meat I have ever been served in a restaurant. It was so small I could hardly see the meat, let alone taste it.

I don’t know if it was just the end of the Christmas season (it was Boxing Day) and the chef was were down to his last rations of meat but it was as if ‘sirlion’ was as much as a rarity or delicacy in Norfolk as fresh swordfish or red snapper might be in land-locked Shropshire. After three mouthfuls, my lunch was over.

Thankfully, the chunky chips – served in a little white paper bag – were divine and some perfect home-made mince pies were served with coffee. I wasn’t exactly full but I headed off towards the beach thinking that I had inadvertently started my post-Christmas ‘diet’ early.

The next day we had lunch with my friends Anthony and Diana Scott at Creake Abbey (Diana Scott below, holding her restaurant menu, with my fiancee Laura Cathcart). The Creake Abbey estate (www.creakeabbey.co.uk)  is nothing like the scale, acreage or splendour of Holkham but its 40 acres of meadow – along with its Augustine monastic ruins that date back to 1206 – make it one of the most enchanting and ‘must-see’ historic attractions of Norfolk.

Their estate neighbours the Norfolk estate of Earl Spencer who enjoys the food at the new Creake Abbey Cafe and Food Hall that he now hosts his gastro-shooting lunches there. From the sound of it, his Edwardian grandfather would doubtless approve of the carefully chosen fresh game and fish dishes – with no ‘steak and chips’ in sight.
The chef at Creake is called Ali Yetman and the restaurant prides itself on being ‘Norfolk and Proud’, with  an award-winning monthly Farmer’s Market, along with a seasonal menu, a smart looking Food Hall with butchery, deli counter, and charcuterie. As I was being shown around by Anthony, we stopped at the cheese counter. ‘We do serve some local Norfolk cheeses’ Anthony said pointing to a modest selection of what looked like mini camemberts. ‘But Norfolk is not really known for its cheese – so we also sell an international selection from France and around the world’.

And the glass cheese counter was suitably groaning with a selection of Europe’s finest cheeses, from Vacheron to Gorgonzola. I was delighted to note that the Food Hall stocked my fiancee’s favourite cheese crackers, Artisan Swedish Crispbread,  made from sourdough, fresh milk, rye flour, wholewheat flower and honey and specially baked not n Sweden I should add – but, yes, Peter’s Yard in Shrewsbury, Shropshire.

The Cafe at Creake Abbey – which is ideally located on one of secret North Norfolk’s roads that cuts through towards the beach and Brancaster – is not only open during the day. That it also opens for dinner on Friday and Saturday  (until 10.30pm) even in winter shows something of the ambition behind the restaurant. When we sat down at a table tucked behind a working Aga. I liked that in the middle of lunch one of the chefs strolled over to pull out an apple crumble from the oven to prove the Aga wasn’t purely decorative.

diana+scott+photo
The first thing I noticed about the menu – and the menu du jour – was that there was no sirlion steak, in fact no any sort of steak to be exact. There was pea and ham soup; pheasant and chesnut broth; steamed local mussels with leek, shallot and white wine cream sauce; homemade ham with sauteed potatoes and fried egg; Longshore cod goujons and hand cut chips with tartar sauce, smoked salmon and a cream cheese sandwich – but no good old steak.
Then I thought, well perhaps that is just as well if my experience of lunch at the Victoria the previous day was anything to go by. Clearly, my future mother in law was right. Steak or beef is is something of a much sought after rare delicacy in Norfolk.
Not so much in private homes (my future mother in law served an excellent fillet of beef on Christmas Eve, but it was from a butcher who is such demand his number is almost ex-directory) who have access to good butchers but rather the hotel/pub/restaurant trade in the county. Hoping for an exceptional and decent-sized local steak when you go out for a pub dinner or restaurant in Norfolk is like hoping for fresh lobster or fresh truffles in a pub in Much Wenlock. When a restaurant (Creake Abbey Cafe above) says it is ‘proud’ to be Norfolk it means they are proud to serve food that the county is renowned for; better to leave the ‘steak’ off the menu.

When you say you are local and seasonal, stick with it. There is nothing at all shameful about not including ‘steak frites’ or filet or beef on a Norfolk gastro-menu. In the Caribbean, one only needs to look at the thin and scrappy quality of the local cows grazing on the few tufts of grass that exist on each island to know you always avoid ordering beef. Whilst I am sure the herds of cattle at the Holkham Hall Farm are of prize-winning quality, and bear no resemblance to the scraggy examples I have seen in Mustique or Barbados, the ration-like size of the portions at the Victoria suggest that Norfolk still has a very long way to go to be famous – like Herefordshire or Argentina – for the quantity and quality of its beef.

As we looked out of the window of the Creake Abbey restaurant and admired the view of the meadow stretching out towards the Spencer estate, (no cows in sight) I asked if there were any local cattle around. Anthony shook his head. When I recounted my anecdote about my portion at the previous day’s lunch, he led me over to the butchery in his Food Hall .

‘We can do you a very good steak but it will have to be special order I’m afraid’ he said. The cook was duly instructed to cut off a huge cut of rump steak – it was not clear if the joint of beef was from Norfolk or not – that was sitting in the butchery section waiting to be sold. The photo at the head of this Blog is of the Creake Abbey butcher holding up apiece of his prized counter beef.
I knew by going off-menu, I was robbing a Norfolk housewife of a cut of much sought after Christmas steak, but to hell with it. I had been living off turkey and gammon and free range eggs (my fiancee’s brother farms 16,000 chickens) so as a Shropshire Lad I was getting beef withdrawl symptoms. Could the county could manage a decent piece of beef?

Th rump steak a la Creake Abbey was extremely good, and extremely large, and it was the clear winner in the Battle of the Steaks between the Victoria and Creake Abbey. But part of the enjoyment was also knowing that steak is something of a special treat in Norfolk, just as it was back in the war and the days of post war rationing.

On leaving the restaurant, after a truly wonderful lunch – that ended with the most indulgent and delectable pear creme caramel and very much non Norfolk cheddar with parsnip and chilli chutney (which was handmade in Foulsham, Norfolk) I noticed in the Creake newsletter that a special day in January had been designated Norfolk ‘Steak Night’.

Friday 17th of January – Steak Night…..Scott our Butcher will be there to advise and cut you your chosen steak, to be taken to the kitchen and cooked for you as you like it.  Try some of our Creake Abbey 28 day matured Rump or Sirloin.   From 6pm…last orders at 8.30pm. Booking advisable. 

 
Judging by the scarcity of beef around in pub and restaurants in Norfolk over Christmas, I would suggest Anthony Scott changes his invitation to ‘booking essential’.